Album Reviews »
Gigwise RSS Feeds Bookmark and Share

Glasvegas - 'Glasvegas' (SonyBMG) Released 08/09/08

the cod anthemics simply dont wash...

September 11, 2008 by David Renshaw
Glasvegas - 'Glasvegas' (SonyBMG) Released 08/09/08 Add to My Fav Bands List
starstarno starno starno star
Google Buzz

Share

People get very angry about hype in relation to music. Many a band are dismissed as “Just a load of hyped up rubbish’ often followed by “All style no substance.” Often these people have a point (The Horrors) often they are wrong (Klaxons). Now Glasvegas have had more than their fare share of hype in the past few months.  From the NME declaring them the best band in Britain to Alan McGee claiming they were the most important band to come out in 20 years, the four black clad Scots have established themselves and press and fan darlings with seemingly nobody daring or wanting to say anything in opposition. This always struck me as being odd given the band's obvious limitations and very clear inspirations. It is, however, not my job to be subjective here, objective is the name of the game - so why are this band being tipped so highly and collecting superlatives at every turn?

On the strength of the band's debut album, ‘Glasvegas’, it’s really very hard to understand why at all. Much of the pre-game talk was about the sincerity, emotion and passion of singer James Allens lyrics, how he documents modern day Britain through his own harrowing tales of abandonment and anguish. Allen’s lyrics focus on bad things happening. From child death to stabbings and how his own Father became estranged from him at an early age. Whilst nobody would wish these things on a fellow human being it does not put Allen and Glasvegas above criticism on their lyrics. Put simply they lay it on thick, really thick. Take ‘Flowers & Football Tops’ for instance is about a mother losing her young son with its title taken from funeral paraphernalia.  “My baby is six feet under, just another number, my daughter without her brother” Allen sings with earnestness not seen since Comic Relief appeals. As if that wasn’t hammy enough the song ends with a verse from ‘You Are My Sunshine’ to truly brighten your day. ‘Geraldine’ meanwhile masquerades as a love song for three minutes, talking of saving lives, holding hands and providing company before the an amazing turn face occurs and Geraldine is revealed to be a social worker, evidentially those longing looks across the care home were government sponsored.

If you feel sympathy for Allen then he provides reasons to hate him on ‘It's My Own Cheating Heart That Makes Me Cry’. “Everybody’s doing it so why can’t I, I tally up tonight’s strangers and stragglers that I’ve kissed”, he says. Presumably you are meant to become Freud at this point and say “Well his father left at an early age and he has serious issues regarding intimacy and love so I should forgive him and give him a big hug.” However the opposite view here would be “Please stop whining you big baby. Yes some bad stuff happened to you in the past and you cheat on your girlfriend. Please stop subjecting my ears to this nonsense.”

Cont. Next Page »
(10)
  • Somebody got out of bed on the wrong side this morning...

    ~ by GC 9/11/2008 Report

    Reply to this comment

  • Great review. It’s about time someone took this overrated band to task. To these ears they sound little more than The Proclaimers pretending to be The Jesus Mary Chain on Stars In Their Eyes. Still, to a generation who’’ve been sold crap like Pete Doherty and the flotsam and jetsam that’’s come in his wake, Glasvegas must be a breath of fresh air. For the rest of us, more evidence that rock music is dying on its arse.

    ~ by Fred Zeppelin 9/11/2008 Report

    Reply to this comment

  • I agree with the reviewer - overrated twaddle!

    ~ by Mikey 9/11/2008 Report

    Reply to this comment

  • Nice review fella... they are terribly limited and will no doubt be forgotten, sooner rather then later hopefully

    ~ by Roger the frog dodger 9/11/2008 Report

    Reply to this comment

  • One of the best reviews I’ve read of the album. Can’’t believe such a wank band got so much hype. Then again, it was the NME who predicted them... file with Gay Dad and Terris

    ~ by Sebastian 9/11/2008 Report

    Reply to this comment

» View all 10 comments

 characters left [+]  


Register now and have your comments approved automatically!

  • The Greatest Band Logo Ever - VOTE NOW! http://bit.ly/bcUBmd (via @gigwise) - Sim, o MUSE está ganhando dos Stones, beijos
    takeapiece on Fri Apr 30 17:10:08 via web
  • The Greatest Band Logo Ever - VOTE NOW! http://bit.ly/bcUBmd (via @gigwise)
    movethatjukebox on Fri Apr 30 16:40:34 via web
  • RT @Gigwise The Who, Rolling Stones, Metallica - Vote For The Greatest Band Logo Ever: In our latest Rate or Slate... http://bit.ly/d7MnqK
    andreaperetti on Fri Apr 30 16:27:07 via web
  • Gotta be the Stones tongue! RT @Gigwise: Green Day, Rolling Stones, Metallica - Vote For The Greatest Band Logo Ever http://bit.ly/d7MnqK
    SSR_Manchester on Fri Apr 30 15:17:23 via TweetDeck
  • #ff @motorpear @dontbeasquare @iamjonsi @juneninth @bat_for_lashes @gigwise
    Expirony on Fri Apr 30 15:09:03 via web
Artist A-Z   # A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z